Missing decisions

We have been writing often on the issue of availability and non-availability of decisions.

While I have been able to access most of the decisions, I am still not able to download the following decisions.

• 1270/MUMNP/2006
• 247/CHE/2005
• IN/PCT/2001/484/CHE
• 381/MUM/2005
• 385/MUM/2005
• 1613/CHE/2006
• 190/CHE/2005
• 1513/CHENP/2004
• 187/MUM/2006
• 105/MUM/2005
• 1005/MUM/2003

If any of the readers have copies of the same, please put in a comment.

Synergy/ 'Surprising Effect' - Indian patent office decisions

For folks interested in the demonstration of synergy / 'surprising effect' (or lack thereof), I recommend reading the following (recent) decisions from the Indian Patent Office (Chennai section):

1) 1873/CHENP/2007

&

2) 3487/CHENP/2005


For a positive decision in the synergy for a composition context, do read the decision in IN/PCT/2002/00977/DEL.